Short answer: run the exit IP through two reputation services (for example IPQualityScore and Scamalytics) and one blocklist checker. Low scores and no blocklist hits mean the IP is clean enough for logins and checkouts. For long-lived accounts, check before you start, then stick with the IP.
What is an IP fraud score?
Fraud-prevention services watch billions of requests and give each IP a risk score. The score goes up when an IP has been seen sending spam, creating fake accounts, attempting card fraud, or appearing on known proxy and VPN lists. Shops, banks, ad networks and social platforms query these scores at signup, login and checkout. A high score means extra captchas, forced verification or a silent block.
Residential and ISP IPs start with a big advantage, because they belong to consumer networks. But a residential pool is shared: if the previous user of an IP abused a site, the IP carries that history for a while.
How to check a proxy's fraud score
First get the exit IP the target site sees:
curl -x http://USER:PASS@HOST:PORT https://api.ipify.org
Then look it up in these free tools:
- IPQualityScore gives a fraud score from 0 to 100 plus flags for proxy, VPN, Tor and recent abuse. It is widely used by shops and ad networks.
- Scamalytics gives a fraud score and a low / medium / high risk label, with the ISP and whether the range is known for anonymising services.
- AbuseIPDB shows community abuse reports, useful to see why an IP is flagged.
- Spamhaus or a multi-blocklist checker like MXToolbox shows whether the IP is on email or exploit blocklists.
Use two of the scoring services, not one. Each company has its own data and their scores often differ.
What is a good score?
Each service publishes its own scale, so read their documentation. As a working rule:
| Result | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Low risk, no blocklists | Clean for practically any site | Use it, and keep it for long-lived accounts |
| Medium risk, "proxy" flag | Known proxy range, no recent abuse | Fine for browsing and data collection; avoid for sensitive signups |
| High risk or recent abuse reports | Recently misused | Get a new session or a different IP |
| On Spamhaus or similar | Listed for spam or malware | Do not use for anything that matters |
A "proxy" flag alone is normal. Many residential IPs carry it because they have been seen in proxy networks. What hurts is the abuse history on top of it.
Fraud scores by proxy type
- Static residential: varies per IP, because you draw from a shared pool. Check the IP at the start of each important session and pick a new session if it scores badly.
- ISP proxies: you rent the IP for the month, so check it once when you receive it. Dedicated ISP IPs stay clean as long as you use them well; see dedicated vs shared ISP proxies.
- Mobile proxies: carrier IPs are shared by thousands of phones through CGNAT, so sites rarely block them hard. Scores are usually low.
- Datacenter: almost always flagged as hosting, whatever the score.
How to get cleaner IPs
- Choose a less crowded pool. The biggest networks are also the most used. Smaller pools, such as Proxare Premium, are shared with fewer people and tend to have fewer flagged IPs.
- Target a city or ISP. Narrower targeting often lands you on IPs that see less proxy traffic.
- Check, then hold. Once you find a clean static IP, keep the session or move the account to a dedicated ISP proxy.
- Behave like a person. No IP stays clean if it fires hundreds of signups an hour. Your own traffic shapes the score.
Automating the check
If you start many sessions, script it: open a session, read the exit IP, query a scoring API, and drop the session if the score is above your limit. IPQualityScore and Scamalytics both offer APIs with a free monthly allowance. It costs a few milliseconds and saves you from burning accounts on dirty IPs.
Compare every provider on Proxare
Static residential, ISP, rotating and mobile proxies from Oxylabs, Decodo, Bright Data, IPRoyal, Geonode, PacketStream and Proxare's own pools, side by side, at the lowest price we can offer.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good fraud score for a proxy?
Low risk on two independent services and no blocklist entries. A proxy or VPN flag alone is common for residential IPs and is not a problem for most sites; recent abuse reports are.
Why is my residential proxy IP flagged?
Residential pools are shared. If a previous user abused a site through the same IP, reputation services remember it for a while. Start a new session to get a different IP, or use a dedicated ISP proxy that only you use.
Do ISP proxies have better fraud scores than residential?
A dedicated ISP proxy is only used by you, so its score reflects only your own behaviour. Residential IPs vary from session to session. Both start far cleaner than datacenter IPs.
Is IPQualityScore accurate?
It is one of the most widely used services, which is why its score matters. No single database is complete, so compare it with a second service such as Scamalytics.